Blogs & Stories

Aunt Dot

By DMFD305R · 2026-11-16 15:07:50

Everybody has a family tree.

Some people have beautiful family trees with branches that spread neatly across generations. They can trace their ancestors back hundreds of years, and everything makes perfect sense.

Then there’s my family.

Somewhere down in Arkansas, somebody took our family tree, twisted the branches together, tied them in a knot, and apparently decided that wasn’t complicated enough.

And that brings me to my Aunt Dot.

Now, Aunt Dot’s real name was Dorothy Virginia Garrett. She was born in 1927 in Delaplaine, Arkansas.

But before I tell you about Aunt Dot, I need to explain something about her family.

Because the confusion didn’t start with Aunt Dot.

It started long before she was born!

Grandpa John and the Fritts Sisters

Let’s go back to a gentleman named John Elbert Garrett, Aunt Dot’s grandfather.

Now, John had already been married to a woman named Anna Stringfield, and they had children together.

Later, John married a woman named Mary Ann Fritts.

John and Mary Ann had two sons, John Wesley Garrett, born in 1890, and Grover Cleveland Garrett, born in 1892.

So far, nothing unusual.

But then Mary Ann died.

Now, John was a widower with children to raise, and apparently he decided that he liked the Fritts family well enough that he ought to stay in it.

So he married Mary Ann’s sister, Susan Christina Fritts!

That’s right. After his wife died, John married his deceased wife’s sister.

Now, before anybody gets too excited, there was no blood relationship between John and either woman.

But it certainly made the family relationships interesting.

John and Susan had children of their own, including Robert Lee Garrett, born in 1902, and Dan Garrett, born in 1905.

And Robert Lee Garrett would eventually become Aunt Dot’s father.

But here’s where things get interesting.

Think about the children from those two marriages.

John Wesley and Grover Cleveland had the same father as Robert and Dan.

But they had different mothers.

So that made them half-brothers.

Except their mothers were sisters!

Which means the boys were also first cousins!

They were half-brothers AND first cousins at the same time!

Now, genealogists actually have a name for this.

They’re called three-quarter siblings.

Ordinary full siblings share both parents. Half-siblings share one parent. But these boys shared a father, and their mothers were full sisters.

Genetically, they were more closely related than ordinary half-brothers, although not as closely related as full brothers on average.

So they were three-quarter brothers.

Now, I don’t know about you, but I’ve heard of having a half-brother.

I’ve heard of having a stepbrother.

But imagine introducing somebody at a family reunion and saying:

“This is my three-quarter brother.”

Somebody’s bound to ask, “Well, what happened to the other quarter?”

And the answer would be, “Nothing! Grandpa just married two sisters!”

Now, remember Robert Lee Garrett, one of those three-quarter brothers.

Robert was Aunt Dot’s father.

And you might think that after all this, the family would settle down and start marrying people who weren’t already connected to the family.

You would be wrong.

The Stepbrother and Stepsister

Robert Lee Garrett grew up and met a young woman named Minerva Dean.

But there was one small complication.

Robert’s mother, Susan Christina Fritts, had married Minerva’s father.

That made Robert and Minerva stepbrother and stepsister.

Now, they weren’t blood relatives. But they were members of the same blended family.

And somewhere along the way, Robert and Minerva decided that being stepbrother and stepsister wasn’t complicated enough.

So they got married!

Let me get this straight.

Robert was already a three-quarter brother to some of his siblings.

And now he had married his stepsister.

At this point, the family tree wasn’t even trying to behave itself.

Robert and Minerva had a daughter in July 1927.

Her name was Dorothy Virginia Garrett.

Everybody called her Dot.

And that’s where our story really begins.

Aunt Dot, the Moonshine Lookout

Unfortunately, Dot’s mother, Minerva, died in January 1930, when Dot was just a little girl.

Dot spent part of her childhood living with her grandfather.

Now, Grandpa had a little business operating behind his cabin.

It wasn’t exactly the kind of business where you put a sign out front and advertised your services.

Grandpa made moonshine!

And young Dot had an important job.

She played outside the cabin, keeping an eye on the road.

Whenever somebody came approaching, she’d holler a warning to Grandpa.

That’s right.

While other little girls were playing with dolls, Aunt Dot was working security for an illegal distillery!

I suppose you could call her the youngest member of the Arkansas Moonshine Protection Agency.

And I imagine Grandpa appreciated having a lookout who didn’t expect much in the way of wages.

But Aunt Dot’s adventures with the family tree were only beginning.

My Mother’s Sister Becomes Her Aunt

After Minerva died, Robert Lee Garrett remarried.

His new wife was Eula Hollaway.

Robert and Eula had a daughter named Alice.

And Alice was my mother.

So Dot and Alice shared the same father, Robert, but had different mothers.

That made them half-sisters.

Simple enough, right?

Well, hold on.

Because Eula Hollaway had a brother named Darrell.

And guess who Aunt Dot married?

Darrell Hollaway!

On November 27, 1944, Aunt Dot married her stepmother’s brother.

Now, think about that.

Dot was my mother’s half-sister.

But Darrell was my mother’s uncle.

And when Dot married Darrell, she also became my mother’s aunt by marriage!

So my mother had a half-sister who was also her aunt!

And I had an Aunt Dot who was my aunt in more ways than one.

Most people have to explain why somebody is called Aunt Dot.

In my family, the question is, “Which reason would you like?”

And if that isn’t confusing enough, wait until you hear about Darrell’s brothers.

Darrell, Harrell, and the Two Dorothy V. Hollaways

Darrell had a twin brother named Harrell.

Yes, Darrell and Harrell.

I suppose their parents figured that if they were going to have twins, they might as well give them names that rhymed.

And Harrell married a woman named Dorothy Vivian.

Now, remember that Aunt Dot’s full name was Dorothy Virginia.

So we had twin brothers, Darrell and Harrell Hollaway, married to two women named Dorothy V. Hollaway!

Imagine the mailman delivering a letter addressed to Mrs. Dorothy V. Hollaway.

Which one gets it?

I imagine he just threw it onto the porch and drove away.

And I wouldn’t blame him.

But we’re still not finished.

Because Aunt Dot had a cousin named Teen.

And Teen was about to make the family tree even more complicated.

Uncle Pringle and Cousin Teen

On Aunt Dot’s mother’s side of the family, there was a man named Pringle.

Pringle was Dot’s uncle.

Now, Pringle had a daughter named Ernestine.

Everybody called her Teen.

That made Dot and Teen first cousins.

And who did Teen marry?

Tom Hollaway!

And who was Tom?

Darrell’s brother!

That’s right.

Aunt Dot married Darrell Hollaway.

Her first cousin Teen married Darrell’s brother Tom Hollaway.

Now, this is where I want you to pay close attention.

Because Dot and Darrell had children.

And Teen and Tom had children.

And those children were related to each other in TWO different ways!

Through their fathers, Darrell and Tom, who were brothers, the children were first cousins.

But through their mothers, Dot and Teen, who were first cousins, those same children were second cousins!

First cousins AND second cousins!

At the same time!

Now, most families are perfectly happy having one relationship between two people.

Not ours.

We apparently believed in getting a second relationship free with every marriage!

And think about Dot and Teen.

They were first cousins by blood.

But because they married brothers, they also became sisters-in-law!

So Aunt Dot could introduce Teen by saying:

“This is my cousin and my sister-in-law.”

And she’d be absolutely correct.

Imagine those children sitting around the dinner table.

One says, “You’re my first cousin.”

The other says, “No, you’re my second cousin.”

And they’re both right!

I can picture a schoolteacher asking one of those children to draw a family tree.

The poor child starts drawing lines between the relatives, runs out of room, turns the paper sideways, and finally raises a hand.

“Teacher, can I have another sheet of paper? My cousins keep connecting to each other!”

Then Came the DNA

Now, I’ve spent years researching my family genealogy.

I’ve traced ancestors across North Carolina, Tennessee, and Arkansas.

I’ve studied census records, examined marriage certificates, followed migration routes, and compared DNA results.

And I’ll tell you something.

DNA is supposed to help genealogists figure out how people are related.

But when families intermarry like this, people can share DNA through multiple ancestral lines.

So I might look at a DNA match and see an amount of shared DNA that suggests one relationship.

But when I trace the family history, I discover that the same person is related to me through two different branches!

I sometimes wonder whether the DNA computer looks at my family tree and says:

“Are you sure you want to continue?”

Now, imagine trying to explain all of this to somebody who doesn’t know anything about genealogy.

“Well, my aunt’s father was a three-quarter brother because his father married two sisters. Then he married his stepsister. After she died, he married another woman whose brother married his daughter. That daughter also had a cousin who married another brother, making their children first cousins and second cousins.”

By the time I finish explaining it, the person I’m talking to is usually looking for the nearest exit.

And I can’t say I blame them.

The Family Tree That Became a Pretzel

But here’s the thing.

Aunt Dot wasn’t just a collection of unusual family relationships.

She was a real person.

She was a little Arkansas girl who lost her mother when she was young.

She grew up during the Great Depression.

She helped her grandfather keep watch over his moonshine still.

She married, raised a family, and became part of a family history that still keeps me entertained generations later.

And that’s why I love genealogy.

Because behind every name and date is a story.

Some are sad.

Some are inspiring.

And some are so tangled that you couldn’t make them up if you tried.

Now, most people can explain their family relationships by saying, “That’s my cousin,” or “That’s my aunt.”

Not my family.

In my family, you might have to say:

“Well, she’s my first cousin through her father, my second cousin through her mother, and her grandmother was married to my grandfather’s brother.”

And then somebody will ask, “Are you sure?”

And I’ll say, “I’ve got the marriage certificates!”

So the next time somebody asks me whether I have any interesting relatives, I just smile.

Because most people have a family tree.

My family has a family pretzel.

It twists around, crosses itself, loops backward, and somehow ends up right back where it started.

And if you ever decide to research your own family history, here’s my advice.

Start with your grandparents.

Work backward carefully.

Keep good records.

And if you discover a man who married two sisters, a pair of twins named Darrell and Harrell, two women named Dorothy V. Hollaway, and a cousin named Teen…

Stop researching. You’re probably related to me!

The End



Webmaster Message